Saved. Check Saved Reviews
40 pp.
| Simon/Beach Lane
| November, 2023
|
Trade
ISBN 9781534493643
$18.99
|
Ebook
ISBN 9781534493650
$10.99
(
2)
K-3
Illustrated by
Alexander Vidal.
Approximately one hundred fifty years ago, and sixty-five million years after the dinosaurs' extinction, scientists discovered fossil treasure troves of bone beds in the western United States. Rather than combine their knowledge and discoveries, two well-known paleontologists, O. C. Marsh and Edward Cope, once friendly colleagues, vied for top billing in the scientific community. They infiltrated, sabotaged, and even destroyed one another's dig sites. They furiously collected bones, identified new species, and published papers. And they both died lonely old men. Vidal's earth-tone palette visually sets the scene for the numerous digs, while a gloomy gray dominates his compositions of the scientists away from these sites, where their distaste for each other plays out in public. He renders his digital dinosaurs and other creatures to reflect what nineteenth-century scientists knew about them, underscoring details from the text. Kurtz effectively creates the escalating tension between Marsh and Cope as she alternates each scientist's action with the other's reaction. In conclusion, she points out that the public was the true winner of this "war," which produced new discoveries and museum exhibits of the hundred and thirty species the two collectively identified. Rounding out this clear and intriguing account are author and illustrator notes, a bibliography, and suggestions for further reading.
Reviewer:
Betty Carter
| Horn Book Magazine Issue:
November, 2023