(3) K-3 Illustrated by Phil Huling. In this Spanish-language version of his Cactus Soup, Kimmel sets "Stone Soup" in revolutionary Mexico. When a group of soldiers comes to town, the inhabitants hide their food, but the clever captain tricks them into bringing out their snacks and having a party. The Spanish text is read-aloud ready, and the desert-hued watercolor and ink illustrations perfectly communicate mood and setting.

Reviewer: Tim Wadham

(2) K-3 Illustrated by Phil Huling. A fast-moving narrative rich in Spanish vocabulary and generous with opportunities for audience participation deftly sets "Stone Soup" in Mexico during the Revolution. Bright watercolors create a vibrant setting bursting with yellows, oranges, greens, and browns that reflect the countryside and the hot tempo of the final fiesta. Appended with a glossary of Spanish words.

Reviewer: Betty Carter | Horn Book Magazine Issue: January, 2005

(2) K-3 Illustrated by Phil Huling. The basic plot follows Perrault's; however, the Hulings' retelling is set in Texas and is filled with country expressions spoken with a Southwestern twang. The sleek illustrations give Puss and the other characters a long, lean look. Cheekily reminiscent of Thomas Hart Benton (and once with a wink at Manet), the sophisticated art is an effective counterpoint to the down-home storytelling.

Reviewer: Luther B. Clegg | Horn Book Magazine Issue: July, 2002