As a digital subscriber, you’ll receive unlimited access to Horn Book web exclusives and extensive archives, as well as access to our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database.
To access other site content, visit The Horn Book homepage.
To continue you need an active subscription to hbook.com.
Subscribe now to gain immediate access to everything hbook.com has to offer, as well as our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database, which contains tens of thousands of short, critical reviews of books published in the United States for young people.
Thank you for registering. To have the latest stories delivered to your inbox, select as many free newsletters as you like below.
No thanks. Return to article
40 pp.
| Chronicle |
October, 2023 |
TradeISBN 9781797214405$17.99
(2)
K-3
Illustrated by
Claire Keane.
When a young girl says she'd like one hundred dogs, her dad logically asks where they would all sleep. The following spread shows her vision (dogs tucked comfortably into bed next to her) alongside her parents' vision (dogs sleeping uncomfortably on top of her). Convinced, the girl agrees to ninety dogs. "But how would you walk 90 dogs?" Again, two very different pictures are conjured--one where the girl holds many leashes while sitting jauntily atop the largest dog and one where the dogs drag her along at top speed. McAnulty ([cf2[Excellent Ed, rev. 5/16) continues the pattern as each time ten fewer dogs are involved. Keane's (illustrator of Make Way, rev. 3/23) loose lines and lively compositions show the opposing viewpoints in comedic scenes of dog bliss (dogs bathing in a large swimming pool) versus dog chaos (dogs piled up in the girl's wading pool). All the bases are covered--feeding, naming, training, vet visiting, grooming, and playing. Down to ten dogs and it's finally time to address a different number--the number two. There's no pretty picture here, as all involved imagine the same stinky scenario. "I think I'd like 1 dog. Please," the girl says, and one she gets. The humor continues on the final spread, as Dad says to Mom, "I can't believe we talked her out of 100 dogs," while the girl, tucked in bed with her happy pup, says, "I can't believe I talked them into getting 1 dog." It's winner takes all here--or maybe just one.