As a digital subscriber, you’ll receive unlimited access to Horn Book web exclusives and extensive archives, as well as access to our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database.
To access other site content, visit The Horn Book homepage.
To continue you need an active subscription to hbook.com.
Subscribe now to gain immediate access to everything hbook.com has to offer, as well as our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database, which contains tens of thousands of short, critical reviews of books published in the United States for young people.
Thank you for registering. To have the latest stories delivered to your inbox, select as many free newsletters as you like below.
No thanks. Return to article
(2)
YA
Translated by Emma Ramadan.
Horror, mystery, sci-fi, historical fiction of sorts--this story partakes of all four. Manon is a tiny child when she's left in the woods after a carriage accident and a scientist's violent murder. Saved from the killers by a flock of butterflies, she's rescued by a peasant who commits her to a convent school--whence she escapes, only to become the victim of a cruel scientist. But who--and what--is this child with red eyes? Brière-Haquet keeps the answer well concealed. Switching points of view often, the omniscient narrator gives us bits of story through many characters--among others, a peasant, a detective, a poetess, a nun, even a dog. Letters to Charles Darwin from the murdered scientist are interspersed throughout, raising questions about humanity and humility (e.g., are the ways humans organize themselves the only ways to be?). A novel of ideas cloaked in skulduggery and populated with textbook villains, the story's momentum is created by the threat of mysterious menace hanging over Manon. The tale is set in 1881 London but includes a few vintage American colloquialisms ("gosh darn it," says one character) while suggesting an environmental message pertinent to the present.
Reviewer: Deirdre F. Baker
| Horn Book Magazine Issue:
September, 2022