ACCESS DIGITIZED EDITION
Guide/Reviews Database
INTERMEDIATE FICTION
Bunce, Elizabeth C.

Premeditated Myrtle: A Myrtle Hardcastle Mystery

359 pp. | Algonquin | May, 2020 | Trade ISBN 978-1-61620-918-6 $17.95
(2) 4-6 This clever and lively Victorian English–village murder mystery starring precocious twelve-year-old fledgling detective Myrtle Hardcastle has all the trappings: households with cooks and governesses and groundskeepers; church luncheons and afternoon teas; mysterious newcomers; missing wills. Also, poisoned elderly ladies: Myrtle's discovery that her neighbor, Miss Wodehouse, did not die of natural causes but was murdered leads to a story filled with spying, deduction, false accusations, red herrings, and danger. Bunce does an excellent job of making Myrtle the lead actor but gives her a strong set of (mostly female) supporters, including her beloved governess, Miss Judson; the family cook; a surprise-twist-at-the-end ally; and one very vocal cat. Myrtle's single-mindedness in solving the murder might wear thin for readers, but she is made sympathetic due to her fraught relationship with her kind but sometimes disapproving prosecutor father, her grief over her mother's death from cancer, and her fervent wish that her father now fall in love with the estimable Miss Judson. Myrtle's narration is Arch with a capital A ("Dear Reader, kindly permit me a pause to properly introduce one of the Key Players in this narrative"), but it suits the novel's setting and subgenre to a T. The last page all but promises a sequel. (For another middle-grade period murder mystery starring an intrepid young female sleuth, check out Marthe Jocelyn's Aggie Morton, Mystery Queen: The Body Under the Piano, rev. 1/20.)
Reviewer: Martha V. Parravano | Horn Book Magazine Issue: May, 2020

RELATED 

INTERMEDIATE FICTION

The Republic of Birds
by Miller, Jessica
INTERMEDIATE FICTION

Atlantis
by Mone, Gregory
INTERMEDIATE FICTION

It Doesn't Take a Genius
by Rhuday-Perkovich, Olugbemisola
INTERMEDIATE FICTION

Cece Rios and the Desert of Souls
by Rivera, Kaela
INTERMEDIATE FICTION

Soul Lanterns
by Kuzki, Shaw
More

Get connected. Join our global community of more than 200,000 librarians and educators.

This coverage is free for all visitors. Your support makes this possible.

We are currently offering this content for free. Sign up now to activate your personal profile, where you can save articles for future viewing.

ALREADY A SUBSCRIBER?