As a digital subscriber, you’ll receive unlimited access to Horn Book web exclusives and extensive archives, as well as access to our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database.
To access other site content, visit The Horn Book homepage.
To continue you need an active subscription to hbook.com.
Subscribe now to gain immediate access to everything hbook.com has to offer, as well as our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database, which contains tens of thousands of short, critical reviews of books published in the United States for young people.
Thank you for registering. To have the latest stories delivered to your inbox, select as many free newsletters as you like below.
No thanks. Return to article
(2)
YA
Sloane is devastated when her idolized older sister, Talley, dies by suicide at age twenty-two. In Talley's pocket, Sloane finds a list headed with the letters TSL, with entries such as "Crescent Street," "Lucy and Ethel," and "A large gentleman's sunset." She guesses that the list might be a puzzle from her games-loving sister, so she fixates on deciphering each clue. Her quest takes her from Minnesota to northern California, where she reunites with an estranged aunt and enlists the help of a boy her age. As the grieving teen uncovers the meaning behind each item, she learns more about her sister's life in the months before she died--and discovers a devastating family secret. Sheinmel treats the topics of suicide and depression with nuance and compassion, beautifully conveying Sloane's feelings of guilt for not being able to save Talley while gently, realistically refuting them. (As Sloane explains, "Someone who dies by suicide is probably someone suffering from a mental illness. It's a medical condition, a potentially fatal one.") The riddles-based plot is absorbing and includes some twists; the fact that not every question is answered is realistic, if somewhat unsatisfying. Most rewarding, however, is the measure of closure the protagonist finds as a result of her search, honoring her sister's life while finding her own path through her grief.
Reviewer: Rachel L. Smith
| Horn Book Magazine Issue:
January, 2020