Cooper, Helen

Saving the Butterfly

(2) K-3 Illustrated by Gill Smith. This affecting and emotional picture book about displacement, tragedy, grief, and hope begins with a dramatic rescue, as two young children arrive by boat to a foreign shore: "There were two of them left in the boat... Brother and sister, lost in the dark sea. They could have died. The bigger one thought they wouldn't survive." The children are housed in what appears to be a refugee camp and their physical needs met; soon, the younger brother makes friends playing outside, and he "hardly ever thought about the time before." The older sister, though, stays inside and apart from others, consumed by her memories and trauma (unspecified) and the responsibility of bearing witness to the past. "She felt she shouldn't forget." Attempting to bring some cheer into their "broken home," the boy catches a butterfly and presents it to his sister. She tries to release it, but it won't depart; eventually, in order to guide the creature, she steps out onto the porch. As the butterfly flies off, the girl, now experiencing the beauty in the light and warmth that surround her, tentatively rejoins the world. Gorgeously evocative and textured mixed-media illustrations are predominantly gray at the beginning and incorporate more and more bright colors as the children respond positively to their environment. Although the shadows are not gone, the girl's self-isolation and profound loneliness have begun to dissipate, following those first steps she's taken toward healing.


Get connected. Join our global community of more than 200,000 librarians and educators.

This coverage is free for all visitors. Your support makes this possible.

We are currently offering this content for free. Sign up now to activate your personal profile, where you can save articles for future viewing.