As a digital subscriber, you’ll receive unlimited access to Horn Book web exclusives and extensive archives, as well as access to our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database.
To access other site content, visit The Horn Book homepage.
To continue you need an active subscription to hbook.com.
Subscribe now to gain immediate access to everything hbook.com has to offer, as well as our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database, which contains tens of thousands of short, critical reviews of books published in the United States for young people.
Thank you for registering. To have the latest stories delivered to your inbox, select as many free newsletters as you like below.
No thanks. Return to article
279 pp.
| Candlewick
| February, 2008
|
TradeISBN 978-0-7636-3161-1$21.99
(3)
4-6
Illustrated by
Inga Moore.
This attractive new edition of Burnett's classic story about the healing power of a garden benefits from Moore's detailed ink and watercolor art. The book is heavily illustrated with scenes grand and expansive in addition to smaller, close-up views of plant and animal life.
303 pp.
| Oxford
| May, 2008
|
TradeISBN 978-0-19-272799-2$9.95
(4)
4-6
Oxford Children's Classics series.
These budget-priced unabridged volumes, compact and sturdily bound with glossy-finished covers, have pleasant but bland pink- (Garden) and purple- (Beauty) heavy cover illustrations and a uniform design. A short "about the author" is included in each. Review covers these Oxford Children's Classics titles: The Secret Garden and Black Beauty.
296 pp.
| HarperFestival
| October, 2007
|
TradeISBN 978-0-06-008137-9$9.99
(4)
4-6
Mary Engelbreit's Classic Library series.
Each of these classic novels features a cover illustration by Mary Engelbreit (intrepid orphans Anne, Sara, and Mary all look pretty much the same, with different hair color) and is packaged with a gimmicky necklace. For libraries, the value of these unabridged hardcovers is the inexpensive price. Review covers these Mary Engelbreit's Classic Library titles: A Little Princess, The Secret Garden, Alice in Wonderland, and Anne of Green Gables.
355 pp.
| HarperFestival
| October, 2007
|
TradeISBN 978-0-06-008136-2$9.99
(4)
4-6
Mary Engelbreit's Classic Library series.
Each of these classic novels features a cover illustration by Mary Engelbreit (intrepid orphans Anne, Sara, and Mary all look pretty much the same, with different hair color) and is packaged with a gimmicky necklace. For libraries, the value of these unabridged hardcovers is the inexpensive price. Review covers these Mary Engelbreit's Classic Library titles: A Little Princess, The Secret Garden, Alice in Wonderland, and Anne of Green Gables.
358 pp.
| HarperFestival
| May, 2005
|
TradeISBN 0-06-075771-X$9.99
(4)
4-6
Charming Classics series.
Illustrated by
Tasha Tudor.
Each of these "deluxe editions" of classic novels are packaged with a gimmicky necklace (thus the "charm" in the series title). For collections, the value of these unabridged hardcovers is the inexpensive price.
199 pp.
| Sterling
| January, 2005
|
TradeISBN 1-4027-1454-8$9.95
(4)
4-6
Illustrated by
Scott McKowen.
The story of Sara Crewe, a wealthy boarding school student who retains her pluck even when her personal circumstances change, is presented in its unabridged format. A handful of scratchboard illustrations (all featuring a monkey that doesn't debut until halfway through the novel) repeat over and over as chapter headers. The book concludes with some open-ended questions to stimulate thought.
241 pp.
| Sterling
| January, 2005
|
TradeISBN 1-4027-1459-9$9.95
(4)
4-6
Illustrated by
Scott McKowen.
The time-tested classic about orphaned Mary Lennox and the neglected walled garden she returns to life is presented with a ribbon bookmark and a list of open-ended questions ("Is an absent father worse than a bad father?") for readers to ponder or discuss. A handful of scratchboard vignette illustrations repeat as chapter headings throughout the book.
(3)
K-3
Illustrated by
Barbara McClintock.
Sketched in pen and washed with watercolors, the small vignettes and larger illustrations that accompany this picture book version of the classic novel clearly depict Sara Crewe's sad reversal of fortune. The retelling retains the basic plot and characterizations and so provides a good introduction to the tale, but it is no substitute for the original story, which has a grander scope and greater emotional resonance.