Saved. Check Saved Reviews
320 pp.
| Delacorte
| May, 2022
|
Trade
ISBN 978-0-59348-585-9
$19.99
|
Library
ISBN 978-0-593-48586-6
$22.99
|
Ebook
ISBN 978-0-593-48587-3
$10.99
(
2)
YA
This formidable prequel to
We Were Liars (rev. 5/14), focusing on the wealthy Sinclair family a generation before that novel's events, opens with a harsh truth, and a spoiler. Johnny, one of the cousins of the first book's protagonist, appears as a ghost to his mother, narrator Carrie, on the family's private island. With the promise to tell him "the worst thing [she] ever did" as a framing device, Carrie flashes back to reveal many of the dark secrets and lies she had helped to perpetuate over the years. In 1987 on the island, seventeen-year-old Carrie is deeply saddened about the drowning death of her youngest sister (the first ghost to appear to her); recovering from the surgery on which her father has insisted to correct her jawline; and beginning a protracted dependence on painkillers and sedatives. Carrie is swept off her feet by Pfeff, a charming, impulsive cad who betrays her in what she feels is the worst possible way. The violent consequences entail a massive cover-up that requires full utilization of the Sinclairs' good standing, privilege, and cunning. The engrossing narration, full of fairy-tale references and family mottos ("Never complain, never explain"), is neither reliable nor neatly wrapped up, but the novel is uncomfortably thought-provoking. The story (understandable on its own but richer when read after
We Were Liars) asks readers to consider hard questions and is impossible to put down.
Reviewer:
Luann Toth
| Horn Book Magazine Issue:
May, 2022